The Tally
GermanyEN · DE

Heard at dinner, checked here

Claims you hear about Germany’s public money, checked against official numbers. Often both sides are quoting a real figure, just a different one.

“Germany stayed within the EU’s 3% deficit limit in 2025.”

Yes, with a shrinking margin

The first estimate in February 2026 put the 2025 deficit at 2.7% of GDP (€119.1bn). The autumn notification to the EU raised it to 2.9% (€132.1bn). In the first half of 2026 the deficit ratio was 3.1%.

Why people disagreeDeficit figures are revised for months after a year ends. A headline from February can be out of date by October.

Sources: Destatis: public deficit 2025, -2.7% of GDP (11 May 2026); Destatis: deficit ratios of EU member states (notification before 1 Oct 2026); BMF: 36th Stability Council meeting, 12 Oct 2026 (Maastricht deficit 2025: 2.9% of GDP); Destatis PM 305/2026: Staatsdefizit 1. Halbjahr 2026

“The government uses 60% of tax money just to run itself.”

False as stated

Core administration (executive and legislative organs, tax and finance administration) costs €89.4bn = 4.2% of all spending. Even all public-sector wages together, including teachers, police, nurses and judges, come to 16.7%. The largest block is social protection at 41.3%.

Why people disagreeThe 60% figure usually mixes up “administration” with social spending and quotes the federal budget.

Sources: Eurostat gov_10a_exp: spending by purpose (COFOG), Germany; Eurostat gov_10a_main: government revenue & spending, Germany

“German GDP is growing.”

True in euros, flat in real terms

Nominal GDP rose +3.1% in 2024 and +3.3% in 2025. After inflation, real growth was 0.0% in 2024 and 0.2% in 2025. Per person it was −0.3% in 2024.

Why people disagreeBoth sides can be “right” depending on whether they adjust for prices and population.

Sources: Eurostat nama_10_gdp / nama_10_pc / prc_hicp_aind

“Bürgergeld is what drives spending up.”

Not in 2025

Monetary social benefits rose 5.9% to €751.2bn in 2025, but Bürgergeld fell 1.5%. The increases came from housing benefit (+26.7%), unemployment benefit (+19.1%), care allowance (+13.1%), social assistance (+7.8%) and, in euros, above all pensions.

Why people disagreeThe debate is loudest about the one item that actually went down.

Sources: Destatis: monetäre Sozialleistungen 2025; Destatis via Berliner Zeitung: Pflegegeld, Sozialhilfe 2025

“Solar power costs us nothing since the EEG levy was abolished.”

False: the cost moved

Since mid-2022 the levy on electricity bills is gone, but the payments to plant operators continue. The federal budget paid €18.5bn in 2024 and €16.5bn in 2025. In 2024 that was €7.89bn more than the €10.6bn budgeted; an extra of up to €8.8bn had been approved.

Why people disagreeThe cost went from your electricity bill to your tax bill. Lower exchange prices for electricity actually make it more expensive for taxpayers.

Sources: Bundestag Drs. 20/14522 (Jan 2025): EEG account payments 2024 = €18.49bn, budgeted €10.6bn; Bundestag hib 35/2025: €18.49bn to the EEG account in 2024, €7.89bn above budget; IHK: EEG account 2025, federal subsidy 16.5 bn; Bundestag hib 540/2024: unplanned extra 8.8 bn for EEG

“Subsidies have almost doubled.”

Partly a counting change

The official federal subsidy report goes from €45.0bn (2023) to €77.6bn (2025). A large part of the jump is that the EEG renewable payments are counted as a subsidy for the first time. Under a wider academic definition, federal financial aid reaches €140.5bn in 2025.

Why people disagreeThree numbers, all “correct”. Ask which definition the speaker is using.

Sources: BMF: 30th Subsidy Report (Oct 2025); 30th Subsidy Report details (2025: 77.6 bn); Wirtschaftsdienst 9/2026: federal financial aid in the wider sense

“Germany is the world’s biggest aid donor.”

True in 2025, with caveats

In 2025 Germany became the largest provider of development aid for the first time ($29.1bn), mostly because US aid collapsed. As a share of national income it is 0.56%, below the 0.7% UN target. The development ministry’s own budget (€10.3bn) is less than half of the total.

Why people disagree“Development aid” is spread over many ministries, so the ministry budget alone undercounts it.

Sources: OECD: preliminary ODA 2025 (press release); OECD Development Co-operation Profile: Germany; D+C: German development cooperation in figures (BMZ €10.3bn)

“A huge part of the budget goes into pensions.”

Depends on the denominator

The federal government paid €116.3bn to the pension insurance in 2024, about a quarter of the federal budget, but only 5.4% of total public spending. Old-age spending of all kinds is €427bn = 20.0%.

Why people disagreeThe government itself says “non-insurance benefits” can’t be defined objectively, so whether the subsidy is “too high” stays a political judgement.

Sources: Bundestag hib 563/2024: payments to pension insurance 2024; Eurostat gov_10a_exp: spending by purpose (COFOG), Germany; Bundestag Drs. 21/1419: no fixed definition of non-insurance benefits

“Migration costs Germany €50bn a year.”

No official number exists

The federal government reports €28bn for refugees and asylum in 2024, including €8.1bn for root causes abroad. The Länder paid €6.7bn in asylum seekers’ benefits. Nobody publishes a consolidated figure across all levels of government, schools, health care and courts.

Why people disagreeAny total you hear is an estimate. Check what it includes.

Sources: Bundestag hib 209/2025: Flüchtlingskosten-Bericht 2024; bpb: Asylbedingte Kosten und Ausgaben; Flüchtlingskosten des Bundes 2023–2025

“The state is bloated: more and more civil servants.”

Context needed

About 5.5 million people worked in the public service in mid-2025 (+95,100 in a year), about 12% of everyone employed. In 1991 it was 6.7 million; the low point was 4.5 million in 2008. Recent growth was mainly in schools, universities and childcare.

Why people disagreeGrowing, yes, but from a historic low, and mostly in education rather than administration.

Sources: Öffentlicher Dienst 2025: 5.5m, +95,100; Destatis via Haufe: public service 2024, growth in schools and childcare

“COVID cost the state €440bn.”

Federal tally, incomplete

The federal finance ministry listed €439.7bn of federal spending for 2020–2022, including €63.5bn for protective equipment, vaccines and tests and over €78bn in business aid. The Länder, social insurance and lost tax revenue are not in this figure.

Why people disagreeA partial number quoted as if it were the full cost.

Sources: Ärzteblatt: Pandemie kostete den Bund 439.7 Mrd. (BMF list); Bundesrechnungshof Bemerkungen (Drs. 20/9700): business aid >78 bn