About & methods
What this is
The Tally shows where public money in Germany comes from and where it goes. We point out where official numbers contradict each other and where data is missing. Germany is the first country; others will follow.
Independent
The Tally is an independent project. It is not affiliated with any party, association or public body. We don’t rate policies; we show numbers, definitions and sources.
Where the numbers come from
602 time series come automatically from Eurostat, the EU’s statistics office. They are fetched again every Monday; last on 17 Nov 2026.
Federal budget line items (2024, 2025, 2026) come from the finance ministry’s open data on bundeshaushalt.de. The files are downloaded by hand because the site doesn’t allow automated downloads.
28 further figures come from 71 individual documents: Destatis, Bundestag papers, the Federal Audit Office, the Bundesbank, the OECD, state parliaments. Each has a source and a date we checked it.
Our rules
- Every number has a source. No number from memory.
- Original documents come before press articles. We use the press only as a pointer.
- When two official figures disagree, we show both and explain the difference in definition.
- Revisions are kept. When a number changes, the old one stays visible.
- Neutral wording. “Leads” are starting points, not conclusions.
Good to know
- Eurostat figures follow the EU’s national accounts (ESA 2010). They cover federal, state and local government and social insurance, so they won’t match the federal budget.
- The most recent years are usually provisional and still get revised.
- Many questions have no official answer. Where that’s the case, we say so.